Henry Van Dyke once said "Use the talents you possess - for the woods would be a very silent place if no birds sang except for the best. " In this unfathomable network of blogs, ideas and intellectuals, I might be just another tiny speck of dust. But while flexing my brains amidst the heavy books of engineering, science and technology, I do crave for my ideas to be articulated; my thoughts to be delineated. So here's the blogspot rendering me ANOTHER CHANCE............a chance to grow up, a chance to live a new life, a chance to learn and a chance to write.
Introducing myself, I am Avinash Upadhyaya a part-time writer, full-time dreamer and engineering graduate from the Birla Institute of Technology & Science, Pilani (India). I hail from Dhemaji a small remote town in Assam - the north-eastern part of India.

Monday, January 11, 2010

Engineering Idiots ??

  Watching Rajkumar Hirani's 3 Idiots for the second time again compelled the swinging mind within me to contemplate 'Was engineering a right choice for me?' 'Was I made to be an engineer?'. It might sound flabbergasting but it was Chetan Bhagat's Five Point Someone that had once inculcated within me a heavy attraction towards this career - an engineering degree from a top institute.That was years ago when I was a high school student growing up in a small town; already nurturing utopian dreams of being an IITian. No idea why, but reading a book that describes three IITians going wayward intensified my dreams of studying in one of these so-called prestigious institutes. Eventually it was not IIT but I did land up in BITS Pilani - a big dream fulfilled. The heart within me satisfied. It was a success in wars called engineering entrance . JEE, AIEEE, BITSAT etc etc. Wars where a single mark propelled you up and down through some thousand ranks. Given the craze and lure of Indian students for this career,engineering seemed to be something majestic;something that made you a man among men.

But is engineering really so dignified? Does everyone of the thousands of students who win the rat-race of engineering entrances end up  being distinguished or even successful engineers? Why do many engineers switch to management, administration, business,politics etc after grueling their minds with sophisticated theories of physics, chemistry and mathematics all through their student life ? If the aim was to go and work in a bank then why study science and technology ? Is engineering education in our nation so pathetic that students lose interest in it during the course of graduation ? Or the engineering entrances in India do not actually select the deserving students who possess an aptitude for engineering ?

These are questions that cannot be answered or retorted back without extensive research and survey. No one is born an engineer or scientist. It is the propensity and surroundings that make one successful in one's field. I did not take up engineering just because someone asked me to do so. Certain ambitions to work in the field of science and technology drove me to this choice of career. But it is undeniable that social or economic circumstances might not deviate me from pursuing my objective in the years to come. This is how engineers work. Maybe this is how the whole system and process called education works.

 

8 comments:

  1. You made a very good point. I had the same debate with my dad and i realised that i'm not just wasting my time here studying engineering. Anyways you wrote it very well. You are really clear about what you want to say. Keep it up!!!!!!!

    ReplyDelete
  2. nicely illustrated ... actually what happens is that WHAT we learn in college does NOT in most cases help us in the future ... and our stream generally changes as our interests swing ....

    ReplyDelete
  3. Very rightly said avinash. Today engineering degree has turned into something more like a prerequisite for taking mba as a higher degree.
    I feel that people have literally begun to misuse the "problem solving strategies" that are taught in engineering to solve and apply to financial and monetary problems, and that too at the cost of a lot good progress that could and can be made if all these people work on what they have worked hard 4 years of their life.

    Avinash you really deserve an applause for the way you have so evidently brought out this scorching topic of today's generation.
    Keep writing...

    ReplyDelete
  4. anonymous,subhayan, aditya thank you very much

    ReplyDelete
  5. Putting up this point is a good initiative..... But dont u think wat is the main problem india is facing in terms of engineers........

    Well when we see most people takin up jobs in high profile industries we find that the company also wants some experience in the field....that is the person should not just be a graduate...he should have the practical knowledge....
    And another problem is after doin graduation from reputed instis. of india we wander abroad for higher prospects.....
    So all the training given to us in four years so that we can carry on here with it in research fields is transferred..... a huge amount of time and money drained...

    Its not the case of only IITs or BITS or oders.....its the case of the engineers of india.... more worried bout the money they'll make rather than the duty they have taken...

    Neways uve brought out things well....

    i too am an Engineering student in an IIT....and am seeing these situations quite often,......

    A well wisher....

    ReplyDelete
  6. excellent thing to think..

    ReplyDelete
  7. i highly appreciate your thoughts which u have written and shared.. a gr8 blog!

    ReplyDelete
  8. Yup...very true n vry well written
    We all keep having fluctuating interests in lyf.....i remem wen i was in class 3 or 4 , i dreamt of bein a pilot,den dreamt of joinin da defense....n wen in class 11,most of us prep 4 engineerin simply bcoz the pasture looks greener than other options + da social convention dat engineerin n medical r da only career options....only aftr comin here,some feel dey were nevr meant to be here

    ReplyDelete